Associate Professor Nesterenko considered the mileage after which car sharing is disadvantageous to Tula n
Car sharing is cheaper than a personal car if the driver travels no more than 5-8 thousand kilometers per year

Car sharing is cheaper than a personal car, if the driver travels for a year no more than 5-8 thousand kilometers. But with a run of more than 20 thousand kilometers, the maintenance of your own car becomes economically more profitable, Natalia Nesterenko, associate professor of the Institute of Economics and Management of the Herzen RSPU, told MK in Tula.
According to the expert, Tulas should take into account not only the cost of individual trips, but also all the costs of the car. Insurance, taxes, maintenance and parking create a constant financial burden, even if the car is idle most of the time.
With an annual run of 5-8 thousand kilometers, or about 13-22 kilometers per day, car sharing and taxis are usually cheaper. The approximate equality of costs occurs at 10-15 thousand kilometers per year. If the Tula regularly overcome more than 20 thousand kilometers, your own car becomes more profitable.
For example, Natalia Nesterenko gave calculations for St. Petersburg. The constant cost of maintaining the machine there is about 113 thousand rubles a year. This amount includes maintenance, tire change, OSAGO, CASCO and transport tax. Additionally, fuel costs are taken into account - an average of 5.5 rubles per kilometer of mileage, while car sharing costs about 12 rubles per kilometer. Taking into account fixed and variable costs, it is possible to determine the point at which the costs of both options are compared.
Car owners also need to consider the loss of market value. The more expensive the car, the more noticeable can be its cheaper for a year.
Thus, for rare trips it is more economical to use rented transport. If you need a car every day, and the routes are varied and long, buying your own car can be a more profitable solution.
By the way, earlier “MK in Tula” told which car brands appeared more often in insurance cases in the Tula region.
According to the statistics of insurers for the nine months of 2026, the leaders were Changan, Geely, BMW, Haval and Skoda.
Among the most frequently involved in accidents were also called Haval M6, Haval Jolion, Lada Vesta, Volkswagen Polo and Lada Largus. Their high accident rate was partly due to their active use in taxis, car sharing and commercial transportation.

