The expert explained the difference between simulated and stuctured caviar
Recently, a lot has been said about the rise in prices for red caviar and that soon it will be available only to the richest segments of the population

New Year is a time when you can not do without red caviar. The circle of those who can now afford it - and before the holidays the cost of fish delicacies will still grow! - is narrowing before our eyes. Current prices (taken in one retail chain) make you sigh and shake your head: 2550 rubles. for 100 g of natural sockey caviar and 2900 rubles. for a 150-gram jar of trout caviar.
Meanwhile, there are on sale, and this has long been known, products that mimic caviar. The Russians cite in the discussions under these news the price of the “Tsar’s” simulated red caviar: the total number of caviar. 119 rubles for a jar. “The main thing is that the “royal”, everyone who bought can feel like a king,” social media users grin gloomyly. And a jar of “simulated sturgeon caviar” 230 g will cost 118 rubles. (the jar is marked with “bursting eggs”). The price of “false black caviar” varies from 77 rubles. to 191 rubles. for a 220-gram capacity.
By the way, the other day, the phrase of the president of the All-Russian Association of Fishery Enterprises, Entrepreneurs and Exporters German Zverev (“Vedomosti”) flew around the social network: “Red caviar prices return to the fair level for the premium product, lost due to a large number of poaching or low-quality products.”.
That’s how, sad Russians, soon real caviar will be completely inaccessible to many “premium product”.
Muscovite Alexei, however, revealed in the discussions, why this product may be needed: “Imagine the imitation of red caviar for decorating dishes.”.
People also note that before pike caviar was relatively cheap - "quite affordable and more than once a year." And then it started to go up in value, too. But it also has a much cheaper imitation, and it is in very high demand.
For clarification on these products, we turned to an expert economist.
- What does “simulated” and “structured” caviar mean?
- Today, structured and simulated caviar products are increasingly present on the market, but it is important to distinguish these concepts, said Svetlana Ilyashenko, associate professor of the Department of International Commerce and Logistics at RANEPA. TR (technical regulation) of the EAEU 040/2016 “On the safety of fish and fish products” refers to simulated food fish products products that reproduce the organoleptic properties of the relevant fish products, and as one of the examples directly refers to structured products. Therefore, from the point of view of technical regulation, structured products are a type of simulated fish products, although in trade these concepts are usually distinguished. For such products, mandatory safety and labeling requirements are established, and the consumer should be able to understand by the name of the product that he is not facing natural caviar.
In natural caviar, continues our interlocutor, the natural structure of eggs is preserved. And structured caviar is a caviar fish product in which the structure of the eggs is formed anew. As raw materials, damaged eggs or caviar mass can be used, to which structural and other technological components are added. The result is a product that looks like natural eggs.
- As for the simulated caviar, it may not contain natural caviar at all, says Svetlana Ilyashenko. Most often, it is produced on the basis of alginates (natural polysaccharides) obtained from seaweed or other structural components, adding fish ingredients, flavors, dyes and other substances, depending on the formulation, to reproduce the color, taste and appearance of natural caviar.
- Who even buys it? What kind of cases is it good for?
- From the point of view of the buyer, the main advantage of such products is obvious - the price. Therefore, they are in demand primarily as a more affordable alternative to significantly increased natural caviar. In addition, substitutes are suitable for situations where caviar performs mainly decorative and taste function: for salads, rolls, banquet snacks, catering. If a person buys caviar for its nutritional value and characteristic taste, a simulated product of natural caviar, of course, will not fully replace it.
We also talked about the composition of such products - is there anything harmful in it?
- To say that simulated or structured caviar products are harmful in themselves would be wrong. Alginates, carrageenan, agar, permitted dyes, preservatives and other food additives are allowed for use subject to established requirements and standards of use. The presence of such components in the composition does not indicate the danger of the product.
The main question, in her opinion, is rather in nutritional value and specific formulation. Everyone knows that natural caviar is a source of full-fledged protein and fats, while a fully simulated product, based on water and structural components, is inferior in nutritional value to it.
- The composition can also be quite a lot of salt, flavorings, flavor enhancers, dyes and preservatives. Therefore, the buyer should pay attention not only to the appearance and price, but also to the composition, the associate professor advises.
Particular care should be taken by people with allergies to fish and fish products - even simulated products can contain fish broth, fish oil or other fish ingredients.
Now on to the sales situation. The situation here, according to her, is heterogeneous, so it would be wrong to talk about a single growth of the entire caviar substitute market.
- According to NTech, in the first half of 2025, about 468.8 tons of structured pike caviar were sold, which is about 8 times more than a year earlier. For comparison, natural pike caviar for the same period was sold only about 6.5 tons. Thus, it was the structured product that actually formed the mass segment of this product category. Simulated red caviar also recorded an increase in the number of purchases: in some periods of 2025, it was from 9 to 18% in annual terms. Therefore, now it is more correct to talk about the expansion of the offer and a noticeable consumer interest in more affordable alternatives to natural caviar.
In short, you should not be afraid of imitation, yet this is an independent product allowed for sale, but I would not like to switch to it instead of red, pleasantly bursting in the mouth, giving taste delight and health benefits of natural eggs ..

