Tuesday, November 17, 2026Moscow
Economy

Offsetting for 21.5 million rubles became the reason for a dispute in the arbitration court of St. Petersburg

The Supreme Court postponed the bankruptcy manager of Stroykomplektmontazh (SCM) payment of 80 thousand rubles of state duty when filing a cassation appeal against the decisions of the Thirteenth Arbitration Court of Appeal and the Arbitration Court of the North-Western District. As follows from the files of the court, the payer was given a delay of payment of 80 until the end of the proceedings on the complaint.

Published
Offsetting for 21.5 million rubles became the reason for a dispute in the arbitration court of St. Petersburg

The Supreme Court postponed the bankruptcy manager of Stroykomplektmontazh (SCM) payment of 80 thousand rubles of state duty when filing a cassation appeal against the decisions of the Thirteenth Arbitration Court of Appeal and the Arbitration Court of the North-Western District. As follows from the files of the court, the payer was given a delay of payment of 80 until the end of the proceedings on the complaint.

It is known that on August 25, the Arbitration Court of the North-Western District confirmed the appeal decision and recognized the claims of Sotex LLC to receive 5.4 million rubles from Stroykomplektmontazh as justified. But the company will be able to satisfy them only at the expense of the property remaining after the payment of debts to creditors included in the register. The cassation complaint of the bankruptcy manager was rejected by the district court and recovered from Stroykomplektmontazh 50 thousand rubles of state duty to the federal budget.

The dispute grew out of contracts for the construction of schools in Murino and St. Petersburg and a hostel in Repino, as well as a contract for the supply of building materials. The appeal considered the debt of Stroykomplektmontazh as the difference between what the company owes Sotex for the work performed and what Sotex must reimburse for electricity and materials supplied.

The court settled the counter obligations - brought them into a single balance and counted against each other, leaving only the final difference to be recovered. The tender manager proved that such a settlement was carried out illegally: the obligations do not stem from a single legal relationship, but actually fall into four groups, and for each of them the debtor's debt to Sotex is 19.8 million rubles. In addition, in his opinion, Sotex missed the limitation period for most of the claims. Cassation did not accept these arguments, since Sotex filed a lawsuit and thereby interrupted the statute of limitations, and the conclusions of the appeal confirm the documents of the case.

In addition, in October, the arbitration court of St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region accepted for production the application of the bankruptcy manager of SCM LLC to challenge the transaction with Sotex LLC in the amount of 21.5 million rubles. The manager believes that because of this, the debtor was left without a large amount that should have gone to creditors. He wants the credit to be invalidated, Sotex’s debt to the debtor restored, and the money returned to the general mass for settlements with creditors.

The history of bankruptcy of SCM LLC began in 2023 with the statement of PKF Quadro Polymer LLC. The court found it justified and on July 31, 2023 introduced a monitoring procedure against the debtor, approving the interim manager.

A statement challenging the deal was initially left without movement. But after correcting the comments, the court accepted it. The manager was also granted a delay in paying the state duty until the dispute was considered.

Revenue of SCM amounted to 51 million rubles for 2021. At this time, the profit of the company, specializing in the construction of engineering communications for water supply and sanitation, gas supply, was 522,000 rubles.

The founder of the organization is Victoria Ivanova. At the same time, it is noted that the company has a mark of the FTS on the inauthenticity of the founder. The organization acts as a defendant in one case of an arbitration court for 4.4 million rubles. As a plaintiff involved in two cases 2.3 million rubles.

Sotex specializes in the construction of residential and non-residential buildings, headed by Ilya Korshunov. The organization acts as a defendant in 37 cases of the arbitration court for 379 million rubles. And the plaintiff in 33 cases of the arbitration court for 556 million rubles.

Source: Московский комсомолец ↗

Share

More on This Story

EconomyThe Ministry of Finance from October 7 will increase the purchase of currency and gold five times

The Ministry of Finance of Russia from October 7 to November 6 intends to buy foreign currency and gold under the budget rule for 279.42 billion rubles. This is five times more than the volume planned a month earlier (55.6 billion rubles).

Коммерсантъ
EconomyThe FT learned how the growing debt burden prevents China from stimulating the economy

China’s debt service will cost 19.2 percent of total government this year, according to a study by the Conference Board

Григорий Лебедев
The head of JPMorgan said that the Russian army could reach Paris if desired
EconomyThe head of JPMorgan said that the Russian army could reach Paris if desired

Dimon said that EU countries cannot afford full-fledged armies and the Russian Armed Forces could reach Paris if desired. The US should support the EU and make more deals with it to avoid fragmentation

Григорий Лебедев
The EIA Briefing

Keep reading, every morning.

The stories that matter, chosen by our editors and in your inbox before 7 a.m. — every weekday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.