Offended by the emoji in a house chat, St. Petersburg himself owed a neighbor
St. Petersburg appealed to the court because of the publication of his photo in the house chat and demanded to recover from the neighbor 50 thousand rubles compensation. The plaintiff stated that the defendant sent his picture with a smiley face to ridicule. However, the court refused to satisfy the claim, said the head of the United press service of the courts of the city Daria Lebedeva in his Telegram channel.

St. Petersburg appealed to the court because of the publication of his photo in the house chat and demanded to recover from the neighbor 50 thousand rubles compensation. The plaintiff stated that the defendant sent his picture with a smiley face to ridicule. However, the court refused to satisfy the claim, said the head of the United press service of the courts of the city Daria Lebedeva in his Telegram channel.
The incident occurred on May 3 this year. It turned out that during the discussion of common house issues, the plaintiff several times left the chat and returned back. One neighbour tried to stop the man by sending a picture of him in dialogue with the caption "Please stop" and a friendly emoji.
The defendant explained to the court that there was no other way to contact the man: the function of sending private messages was absent, and only a photo was displayed in the profile. He said he had no intention of insulting his neighbor.
As a result, the court took into account the motives of the defendant and the emoji “Smiling Face”, which symbolizes good nature and joy. In addition, the court noted that a citizen’s voluntary publication of his picture in the public domain can be regarded as consent to its further use, especially since the picture was processed using artificial intelligence.
In addition to the refusal of the claim, the court ordered the St. Petersburger to pay the defendant 20 thousand rubles to pay for the services of a representative.



