Saturday, November 21, 2026Moscow
Society

How to act a consumer if his rights are violated, explained the capital judge

What to do if you sold low-quality goods or services, the correspondent of the agency “Minsk-Novosti” learned from the judge.

Published
How to act a consumer if his rights are violated, explained the capital judge
photo

What to do if you sold low-quality goods or services, the correspondent of the agency “Minsk-Novosti” learned from the judge of the court of the Frunze district Vyacheslav Markovich.

The photo is illustrative in nature

Statements of claim and dispute resolution

- What consumer protection lawsuits do citizens take to court?

- Most often, lawsuits are filed related to violation of rights when concluding and executing retail sales contracts, paid services, domestic contracts, complex agreements of these types of transactions, Markovich said. Less often there are claims caused by the need to resolve disputes arising from contracts for the creation of shared construction facilities, the provision of housing and communal services.

- What atypical cases have you encountered?

- In judicial practice, there is no tendency to receive identical claims in the field of consumer protection for consideration due to the different circumstances of the conclusion, performance of the terms of the contract, as well as the behavior of the parties in the event of a dispute within the framework of the obligation. To a greater extent, the requirements related to the need to resolve disputes arising from the provision of veterinary, cosmetic services, the implementation of works on the arrangement of burial sites are not typical. This is due to the lack of technical regulatory legal acts, medical, veterinary protocols and other local documentation that allows to give a legal assessment of the quality of the works or services performed by the contractor on the basis of the immediate requirements of the legislation.

photo

The photo is illustrative, created by AI

So the court appealed to the Minsk, who indicated that the defendant was poorly provided veterinary services for the treatment of his cat, in connection with which the death of the animal. He claimed that in the treatment of the pet, a drug was used that was not registered in the territory of the Republic of Belarus in the manner prescribed by law.

In order to assess the quality of the services rendered by the defendant, the presence or absence of a link between the services rendered and the ensuing consequences, a specialist in the field of veterinary services was interviewed by the court. In addition, an examination was appointed and an assessment was given to the materials of the inspection and the responses of state bodies in the field of veterinary and food supervision.

The expert’s conclusion and other evidence in the case confirmed the absence of a causal relationship between the quality of the services provided by the defendant and the death of the animal. The fact of quality provision of services to the plaintiff under the concluded contract was established. However, the client was not provided with complete and reliable information about the drugs used in the treatment of animals. The name of the drug was not specified (which was in fact a mixture of registered drugs). The court recovered in favor of the consumer the amount of material compensation for moral damage in connection with violations of consumer rights by the contractor.

photo

The photo is illustrative in nature

Pre-trial claim

- How can a consumer act if their rights are violated?

- In accordance with Chapter 6 of the Law “On Protection of Consumer Rights”, the Republic of Belarus provides for the possibility of protecting violated consumer rights by public associations, executive authorities, which have the right to provide free legal assistance to consumers in connection with the violation of their rights: to give advice, conduct claim work, prepare claims, bring them to court, represent and support the consumer’s position in court sessions.

Independent protection of consumer rights involves, first of all, the direction of a pre-trial claim containing the requirements of the consumer provided for by the Law.

Requirements, which are declared by the consumer under the provisions of the Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights", can sometimes be mutually exclusive, in connection with which it is necessary to clearly define the way of protection of the violated right: either to demand termination of the contract, return of paid funds, proportional to the reduction of the price under the contract, or otherwise.

Requirements of the consumer can be stated by submitting a written claim, leaving an entry in the book of comments and suggestions of the second party under the contract or sent using the electronic communication system (if there is reliable information about the ownership of the electronic communication means to the addressee).

When determining the court for filing a claim for the protection of the violated right, the general rules of jurisdiction should be taken into account, according to which the application for initiation of proceedings in the case is submitted to the court at the place of residence of the defendant. Also in this category of cases, claims can be filed at the place of residence or location of the plaintiff, or at the place of execution of the contract, or at the place of harm.

Consumers upon presentation of the above requirements to the courts are exempt from payment of state duty. However, in case of refusal of the plaintiff to satisfy the claim, the state duty, from the payment of which the consumer was exempted when filing the claim, will be recovered from him to the state income in accordance with Article 151 of the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Belarus. Therefore, the decision to file a claim in court should be balanced, deliberate and based on the norms of current legislation.

photo

Photo is illustrative, freepik.com

Online commerce

- Currently, there is an active increase in the number of online purchases.

The nature of disputes between the seller and the buyer of goods purchased through e-commerce is due to a number of features that relate to the remote order of selection of goods, its transportation and issuance. These legal relations can be entered by third parties – cargo carriers, trading platforms.

At the same time, the purchase of goods through e-commerce is a very convenient and prompt way to meet the needs of consumers. This method of purchasing goods is not an obstacle to the resolution of consumer claims by courts and the protection of violated rights. In some cases, this method of making a transaction provides an opportunity to obtain more complete and reliable information about the circumstances of its commission due to a clear and consistent procedure for reflecting legally significant actions.

They say that such disputes are better resolved out of court. Why?

- This has several advantages for the parties to the obligation. First of all, participants can save significant amounts of money necessary for forensic examinations, payment of state duty, expenses of public associations and other representatives, a fine, a penalty.

The parties have the right to independently conduct research on the quality of goods, works, services in the manner prescribed by law. They also have the right to determine various options for resolving the dispute, which implies the possibility of a more prompt and rational settlement of the conflict.

Requirements that can be claimed by the consumer in case of violation of his rights are determined by law. Their variety depends on the contract concluded between the parties, as well as the type of infringed consumer rights.

Source: Минск-новости ↗

Share

More on This Story

The son of Dmitry Gudkov committed suicide
SocietyThe son of Dmitry Gudkov committed suicide

Ivan Gudkov, the son of oppositionist Dmitry Gudkov and his first wife, Sophia Kapkova, committed suicide. Ksenia Sobchak said that he reported on the difficulties of emigration

Яна Соловьева
In the fighter MMA “Nikarho” shot from the trauma in the center of Vladikavkaz
SocietyIn the fighter MMA “Nikarho” shot from the trauma in the center of Vladikavkaz

In the center of Vladikavkaz, a man was injured as a result of shooting from a traumatic pistol, the Ministry of Internal Affairs for North Ossetia reports.

Виктория Хабарова, Александра Озерова
PCT reported 23 complaints of sick tourists from a hotel in Turkey
SocietyPCT reported 23 complaints of sick tourists from a hotel in Turkey

Since August, insurance companies have recorded 23 appeals from tourists vacationing in the Turkish hotel Bosphorus Sorgun, with similar complaints of poor health, told RBC in the press service of the Russian Union of Travel Industry (PCT).

Евгения Сорокина, Виктория Хабарова
The EIA Briefing

Keep reading, every morning.

The stories that matter, chosen by our editors and in your inbox before 7 a.m. — every weekday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.