Nurses and firefighter fail to challenge suspension during pandemic
ECHR upholds French mandate for Covid-19 vaccination for health workers

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that France, by suspending unvaccinated health workers and a firefighter from work, has not violated their right to privacy. The court agreed that there had been interference with private medical decisions, but found it justified.
The plaintiffs were two French nurses Florence de Aro and Vanessa Ketstroy and firefighter Pierric Thevenon. All three refused vaccination and spent 15 to 20 months without pay. They appealed to the ECHR, demanding to recognize that the mandate introduced in August 2021 violates their right to privacy.
However, French judges agreed that the country intervened in a private medical decision, but officials were given wide discretion during the pandemic. All three have worked with vulnerable populations, and France has relied on expert advice that vaccination protects workers from serious illnesses, reduces the risk to patients, and keeps hospitals and emergency services running. The judges acknowledged that some of the applicants had not been paid their salaries for a long time, but found no violations of privacy.
Judge Andreas Zund drew attention to an exception to the emergency rules: a vaccinated health worker with a positive Covid-19 test but no symptoms could sometimes remain on duty to prevent disruptions in patient care, and an unvaccinated colleague with a negative test result would still go home without pay. In his opinion, France should consider regular testing, improvement of protective equipment or transfer to another job, and if no option allows the employee to stay, the question of a minimum benefit.
Rotterdam specialist Maria Eva Feldes said judges should have asked what France has done to review suspensions when conditions change and what evidence supports that less stringent measures still do not protect patients.
Labor law specialist Silvio Sonnati noted that it also showed she could still work as a nurse, albeit overseas. Italy initially required employers to look for other responsibilities for unvaccinated health workers before suspending them, he said, but then rescinded that rule: "The suspension should be a last resort, not an automatic consequence.".
The nurse and president of the French union, Catherine Buissoux, supported Zund’s position and criticized France for leaving temporarily suspended workers without income or financial support, unlike many other European countries; her union supports dozens of compensation claims in French courts: “Free and informed consent is a fundamental principle for both patients and health workers.”.
Labor lawyer Marielle Zucchillo said the ruling largely confirms the approach of the French courts that workers can still sue on the grounds of causing serious harm to their lives or careers, although the outcome of the Tevenon case showed how difficult it can be.
All three returned to their jobs. Either party has three months to apply to the Grand Chamber for review of the decision, but only in exceptional cases, and the decision becomes final if no one makes such a request or the court rejects the request.



