In Kalmykia, the insurer was punished for slowness
Insurance joint-stock company RESO-Garantia appealed to the court with an application to cancel the decision of the financial commissioner.

Insurance joint-stock company RESO-Garantia appealed to the court with an application to cancel the decision of the financial commissioner.
The point. June 14, 2023 due to the fault of the driver V. there was an accident, as a result of which mechanical damage was caused to the car Y. The civil liability of Y. at the time of the accident was insured in JSC RESO-Garantia under the OSAGO agreement. On June 15, 2023, an assignment agreement (assignment of the right of claim) was concluded between Y. (assignor) and N. (assignee), according to which the assignor transfers, and the assignee accepts the right to claim insurance compensation, a fine, compensation for moral damage, financial sanctions - procedural rights related to damage to the vehicle.
In July 2025, N. appealed to JSC RESO-Garantia with an application for payment of a penalty in connection with violation of the term of payment of insurance compensation, but was refused. After N. appealed to the financial Commissioner, whose decision from the insurance company recovered a penalty. Referring to the fact that the right to recover a penalty for N. under the contract of assignment was not transferred and, therefore, the latter did not have such a right, the insurance company considered the obligations to pay it illegal.
But the Sarpinsky district court refused the application of the insurance company. And the judicial board for civil cases of the Supreme Court of Kalmykia found no grounds for annulment of the court decision.
“The right of the original creditor shall pass to the new creditor to the extent and under the conditions that existed at the time of the transfer of the right, including the rights related to the main claim, including the claim for a penalty and the amount of the financial sanction to the insurer obliged to make insurance payment in accordance with the law on CMTPL.
It follows from the contract of assignment (assignment of the right of claim) that Y. (assignor) transferred, and N. (assignee) accepted the right to claim insurance compensation, fine, compensation for moral damage, financial sanction, other procedural rights related to damage to the vehicle as a result of an accident, the court panel concluded.
The court recognized as lawful the decision of the financial commissioner to pay a penalty by the insurer for the fact that he does not comply with the term of insurance payment.



