COP banned to automatically deprive buyers of the right to land
The Constitutional Court of Russia decided to take into account the good faith of buyers when deciding on the withdrawal of land, if the right of the former owner to land was later recognized as illegal.
The Constitutional Court of Russia decided to take into account the good faith of buyers when deciding on the withdrawal of land, if the right of the former owner to land was later recognized as illegal. Rg.ru reports.
The reason was the story of a resident of the Moscow region Olga Ostroumova. According to the newspaper, she sold the apartment and bought land to build a house on the site for herself, her daughter and two grandchildren. However, the administration of the Leninsky city district demanded to take away the land and abolish the right of ownership.
It turned out that earlier this land was part of a large plot. Its former owner received the property through the court, then divided the territory and sold individual plots. The court decision was later overturned. Because of this, buyers who purchased land from the previous owner were at risk of losing property.
Ostroumova appealed to the Constitutional Court, believing that she wanted to deprive the site because of decisions to which she had no relation.
The Constitutional Court agreed with the woman in part. The judges explained that the cancellation of the previous court decision in itself does not mean that new owners need to take away land. In considering such disputes, the courts must ascertain whether the buyer knew about the problems with the plot and whether he acted in good faith. Limitation periods should also be considered.
The Constitutional Court separately noted that if a person legally built a residential house on the site, this may indicate that the state has long recognized his right to land.
The provisions of the Civil Code and the Real Estate Registration Act were found by the Constitutional Court to be in conformity with the Constitution. The case of Olga Ostroumova should be reviewed.
The question of the protection of conscientious buyers of land has already become the subject of consideration by the highest courts. In July, the Supreme Court clarified that the buyer could not be considered unscrupulous just because the site subsequently ended up on the territory of the forest fund. If in the Unified State Register of Real Estate there was no information about the special status of the land and a person could not know about it, the courts must take these circumstances into account. At the same time, the status of a bona fide buyer does not always guarantee the preservation of the site: for example, the land of the forest fund and reserves cannot be transferred to private ownership.



