The court decided how rich to pay alimony after the complaint of Matvey Safonov
The Constitutional Court, after considering the complaint of the goalkeeper of the Russian national team, noted that alimony “does not involve introducing the child to the luxurious life of parents.” Courts have the right to reduce the amount of alimony, and the decision in the case of Matvey Safonov will be reviewed

The Constitutional Court ruled on the complaint of the goalkeeper of PSG and the Russian national team Matvey Safonov about alimony for super-income. In January 2024, the Nikulinsky District Court of Moscow recovered from him alimony for his daughter of 2021 in the amount of 1/4 of her earnings. Safonov, whose income is related to professional sports, asked to set a fixed amount commensurate with the needs of the child and the income of the former spouse.
The lower courts refused the applicant, stating that a stable and high income did not constitute grounds for derogation from the equity principle. Safonov noted that before the trial he voluntarily spent about 9 million rubles on the child, and after the decision he paid about 62 million rubles as alimony, which many times exceeds the real needs of the minor.
The Constitutional Court recognized the contested norm not contrary to the Constitution, but determined its constitutional and legal meaning, obliging the courts to take into account the real needs of the child. “Automatic application of the alimony calculation mechanism as a proportion of high incomes without the possibility of using a different calculation option ... leads to the deprivation of the payer of alimony property, which is not due to the constitutional purpose of alimony, the resolution says.
The court decision emphasizes that alimony is targeted and is spent on the maintenance, upbringing and education of the child. The recovery of excess income should not be turned into a “source of formation of an excessive level of child support”, “means of redistribution of income” or “punishment for the payer” in the conflict relations of former spouses. The court also referred to foreign experience, according to which alimony “does not involve the introduction of the child to the luxurious life of parents” and “does not serve to enrich the second parent.”.
As a criterion for assessing “super-high” income, the COP proposed to use tax legislation. Since incomes over 2.4 million rubles per year (an average of 200 thousand rubles per month) are subject to personal income tax at higher rates, courts can consider them as high.
The amount of alimony significantly exceeding 200 thousand rubles should be considered by the courts as sufficient to meet the real and reasonable needs of the minor. This amount ensures the balance of interests of all participants in legal relations, if the real need for large funds is not proved (for example, due to the state of health of the child).
As a result, the Constitutional Court ruled that the decisions in the Safonov case should be reviewed insofar as the enforcement decisions adopted in this case have not yet been implemented. The Constitutional Court also indicated to the federal legislator the possibility to specify the conditions for the recovery of alimony and provide additional criteria for courts.
“The Constitutional Court stressed that this rule does not exclude the possibility of the court to reduce the amount of alimony received as a result of this equity principle in the event that the payer’s income is so high in terms of the level that the alimony received as a result does not correspond to the real reasonable needs of the child,” Judge Evgeny Taribo explained to journalists the position of the Constitutional Court.
PSG goalkeeper Matvey Safonov in July filed a complaint with the Constitutional Court against the Family Code's provision for the payment of a quarter of alimony income. The rule concerns paragraph 1 of article 81 of the code, according to which in the absence of an agreement alimony for one child is recovered by the court in the amount of one quarter of income.
Safonov was married to Anastasia Kazachek. In October 2021, it became known about the divorce of the couple, after which the former spouses began to sue for alimony for their daughter Maya (born in the summer of 2021). As a result, the court sided with his ex-wife, and the football player paid a debt on alimony in the amount of 64 million rubles.
The goalkeeper indicated that he gave his daughter an apartment with a market value of about 57 million rubles, paid for repairs and improvement of housing. In his opinion, the use of a fixed share of income in the case of high earnings can lead to payments “tens or hundreds of thousands of times” higher than the real needs of the child, and create the risk of unjustified enrichment of the second parent.
Andrey Klishas, the head of the Federation Council Committee on Constitutional Legislation, said that Russian legislation already allows courts to limit the amount of alimony with an excessively high income of a parent. Klishas admitted that the amounts involved in Safonov’s case “really make an impression.” However, the large amount of payments, he said, does not yet indicate the unconstitutionality of the norm. If the application of the current settlement procedure really violates the rights of the player, he should declare this in the court of general jurisdiction.



