The court has protected 21-year-old Tula from the return of pension overpayment of 218 thousand
The Tula regional court refused the regional branch of the Social Fund of Russia in the recovery of 21-year-old resident of Uzlova more than 218 thousand rubles of pension payments

The Tula regional court refused the regional branch of the Social Fund of Russia in the recovery of 21-year-old resident of Uzlova more than 218 thousand rubles of pension payments. The young man continued to receive a survivor’s pension after dropping out of college, which caused discontent of the relevant department, the press service of the Tula Regional Court told MK in Tula.
The proceedings followed... However, the court found no bad faith in the actions of the guy.
As follows from the materials of the case, the young man was appointed an insurance pension after the death of his father on March 24, 2021. When making payments, he was warned that changes affecting the right to receive money, including expulsion from an educational institution, must be reported to the pension authority.
It was later revealed that the young man left the college of his own free will on June 28, 2024. Information about this educational institution passed to the Social Fund only on January 29, 2026. For the period from July 2024 to October 2025, an overpayment of 218,624 rubles 55 kopecks was formed.
This amount was requested to be returned through the court.
The district court that heard the case initially found that the defendant was still a minor at the time of the pension. He dropped out of college because he needed money and was going to get a job.
However, in October 2024, the young man went to military service. Moreover, the fact that after the expulsion he continues to illegally receive a pension, the young man learned from colleagues.
He did not immediately contact the pension authority. After returning from service, he independently contacted the department to stop payments, and provided a certificate from the college.
With these conclusions, the pension authority disagreed and appealed the decision. However, the judicial board for civil cases of the Tula Regional Court upheld the refusal to recover money in force.
When considering the appeal, the court referred to the position of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation: it is possible to return an overpaid survivor's pension only if the dishonesty of the recipient is proved. At the same time, the pension authority must confirm that the citizen acted dishonestly.
In the present case, no such evidence was provided. The court also pointed to the shortcomings of the control by the pension authority over the correctness of spending budget funds. As a result, they did not collect 218.6 thousand rubles from the young man.
Earlier, MK in Tula told about another legal dispute related to the return of state aid.
Then the Suvorov interdistrict court ordered the resident of the region to return 256.5 thousand rubles received under the social contract for the development of their own business.
The reason was the lack of documents confirming the targeted expenditure of allocated funds. Due to violations, the contract was terminated, and the payment was demanded to be returned.



