Sunday, November 22, 2026Moscow
Sports

"Rules are not for everyone." How Magnus Carlsen angered the chess world

Norwegian grandmaster Magnus Carlsen took advantage of a loophole in the rules of the experimental tournament Total Chess, which he had not thought about before. RBC Sport reveals how his actions angered the chess world

Published
"Rules are not for everyone." How Magnus Carlsen angered the chess world

Norway's grandmaster, 16th world champion Magnus Carlsen, took advantage of a loophole in the Total Chess World Championship rules to skip games he deemed "useless.".

How his decision angered the chess community and drew attention to the shortcomings of the new format of competitions - in the material "RBC Sport".

The Total Chess World Championship Tour was held in Budapest from 10 to 20 November. The format of the tournament was experimental: in each match, players competed in blitz, rapid and “fast classics”. The victory in the fast classics brought 8 points at once - more than in other disciplines.

Chronology of "demarche" Carlsen

The first resonant episode with Carlsen happened on November 17 in a match against chess player from Kazakhstan Bibisara Asaubayeva. After a confident victory in the blitz and Rapid (11.5: 0.5), Carlsen did not reach the final game in the quick classic. Then the girl waited 15 minutes, after which she was awarded a technical victory (8 points). In the end, Carlsen still won the match - 11.5:8.5.

The next day, history repeated itself in a second match between them. Carlsen again secured the lead (10-2) and again refused to play a quick classic. He was technically defeated, but he still won the match.

On the last day of the tournament, Carlsen played with Russian Vladislav Artemyev for 17th place. He again skipped the rapid game to save strength for the decisive party in the fast classic, and won it. But Artemyev won back on the second day, and everything was decided in an additional decisive game - Carlsen won and took 17th place there.

Carlsen's example was contagious. American Abhimanyu Mishra and Hungarian Richard Rapport also did not reach their final games in the quick classics when the outcome of their matches was already decided.

How Carlsen explained his actions

The tournament was held in a pilot format, and for the rejection of the game, the rules provided only for a technical defeat. Carlsen said he didn't play because the outcome of the game no longer mattered. "The only consequence of not showing up is a defeat in a completely useless game," he said during the tournament.

Such a move could help him maintain his rating. According to the rules of the International Chess Federation (FIDE), technical defeat does not affect the rating in classical chess, whereas a draw would cost 3.5 points and a defeat would cost 8.5. Before the tournament, Carlsen had already lost 22 points and risked falling below 2800 for the first time in 15 years (now he has 2804 points in the live rating).

In addition, Carlsen’s closest pursuer, American Fabiano Caruana, successfully performed in Budapest and came close to him.

After the tournament, Carlsen admitted that he was "tired and fed up and doesn't play at all." The chess player added that he felt obliged to perform at the Total Chess tournament, since he supported the idea of competitions with different formats.

He also said he doesn’t care about other players because they are “in completely different places.” “I’ve been used over the years to being able to get something on my own terms because the organizers need me more than I need them,” he added.

The reaction of the chess community to Carlsen's actions

The non-appearance caused criticism in the chess community. FIDE Executive Advisor Emil Sutowski on his X page called Carlsen's behavior "pathetic and unsportsmanlike." He also said the Norwegian "set a very bad example" for other leading players.

Russian grandmaster Jan Nepomnyshchy has taken the toughest stance, saying Carlsen should be excluded from the tournament. According to him, at a technical meeting, the players were warned that each game must be played. "But as they say, the rules aren't for everyone," Nepomnyshny said in a ChessBase India video on YouTube.

French grandmaster Maxime Vacher-Lagrave called Carlsen a "cry" in his post at X after the tournament ended.

American grandmaster Hikaru Nakamura, after the incident with Bibisara Asaubayeva, called Carlsen's behavior "completely unacceptable." He also noted that the situation could negatively affect the reputation of Carlsen and the international prestige of chess.

Some members of the chess community reacted more restrained to the situation. Russian grandmaster Vladislav Artemyev, Carlsen's rival in the match for 17th place, expressed his understanding of the choice of actions of the Norwegian.

Honestly, by the end of the tournament I was a bit tired and the opportunity isn’t that bad. But it's all a little weird, Artemyev said in a ChessBase India video on YouTube.

FIDE Deputy President Vishwanathan Anand pointed to a gap in Total Chess rules. He noted that he “didn’t even think it was possible” and that the problem was that players were able to choose which games to play until the match was over. Anand proposed to tighten the regulations, for example, by introducing fines for missing lots.

Source: РБК ↗

Share

More on This Story

Star who returned: Trusova brilliantly won the tournament in Kazakhstan
SportsStar who returned: Trusova brilliantly won the tournament in Kazakhstan

Alexandra Ignatova (Trusova) won the Denis Ten Memorial in Almaty, scoring 226.01 points. Silver from the Korean Kim Yu Jae (209.20), bronze from the Kazakh Sophia Samodelkina (204.36). The Russian performed a quadruple lutz, updating personal records. This is the second return of the athlete after the birth of his son in 2025. She had previously taken silver in Tokyo. Maria Zakharova was fifth, Dina Khusnutdinova was seventh. The victory confirmed the successful resumption of the career of the figure skater in the staff of Eteri Tutberidze.

МК
In St. Petersburg starts the IX World Championship in restaurant sports WFRS
SportsIn St. Petersburg starts the IX World Championship in restaurant sports WFRS

Today, October 21, 2026, the IX World Restaurant Sport Championship WFRS (World Federation of Restaurant Sport) opens in the Northern capital. For five days, 16 teams representing all continents of the planet will compete for the title of strongest and world champions.

EIA Staff
Valieva withdrew from the stage of the Grand Prix of Russia in Kazan
SportsValieva withdrew from the stage of the Grand Prix of Russia in Kazan

Kamila Valieva will miss the Kazan stage of the Grand Prix of Russia in figure skating, scheduled for October 17-18

МК
The EIA Briefing

Keep reading, every morning.

The stories that matter, chosen by our editors and in your inbox before 7 a.m. — every weekday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.