Controlled by algorithms. Why is the political landscape changing in Europe?
The demands of society and the elite in the EU are becoming less and less identical. This is evidenced by recent electoral campaigns. What does it represent today...

The demands of society and the elite in the EU are becoming less and less identical. This is evidenced by recent electoral campaigns. What is the party room in the West today? To what extent do parties in the European Union reflect voters’ sentiments? What is the future?

Modern Europe is increasingly being compared to the orchestra on the Titanic: real problems are growing like a snowball and become clearly uncontrollable, but Brussels defiantly ignores them, persistently and against all odds promoting its political line. There are many problems in the EU, and they are quite systemic: rising energy prices, uncontrolled migration, de-industrialization, leading to job losses, falling living standards, and this is not to mention the Ukrainian conflict, which puts pressure on Europeans. Why have the classic old European parties been unable to generate voters’ acceptable responses, as evidenced by the rise of far-right parties, which until recently were invariably marginal outsiders and are now moving steadily to the center of the political spectrum? In fact, this transformation is quite logical. The classical party is a mediator who brings together the interests of business, government and society. The wishes of the business, which mainly pays for their activities, of course, ahead. The demands of society have changed over time, giving rise to a change in the ideological agenda. Thus, European liberalism – and all mainstream parties in Europe are liberal in one way or another and operate within this semantic framework – began as economic liberalism. It is a free market and a minimal state that opens up broad prospects for entrepreneurship and corporations. However, the free market in its pure form did not last long: large corporations were isolated and the market was monopolized. This changed the demand of business: a large corporation, which came to power through the party, is already interested in consolidating the existing state of affairs, and the state was thus charged with supporting the existing monopolies - both through state orders and by erecting barriers for competitors. In other words, the free market and the minimal state have at some point ceased to be necessary and even become undesirable. Correspondingly, liberalism has also changed – it has quietly turned into social liberalism, which sounds quite attractive – it is a declaration of individual freedoms and social responsibility of the state, i.e. something outwardly very similar to socialism. True, only outwardly, the devil, as always, is in the details: freedom has become freedom to advance the LGBT agenda, multiculturalism and migration. Business interests are in the first place again. The LGBT community, from the point of view of Keynesian economics (where the main task is to stimulate inflation to give up savings, all money should work) is the ideal buyer. The lack of plans for children implies a minimum of savings, everything is spent on consumption, due to which it approaches the luxury, because in this scenario much can be afforded.
Migration is also a relief for business: automation and digitalization of production and simplification of labor make the worker’s high qualifications excessive, because his main function now is to monitor the readings of devices and press buttons in time. Uneducated migrants can cope with this, and the mere fact of pressure on the labor market is enough reason to freeze wages. Yes, the costs of migration are borne by governments, but the profits remain with businesses. This is called, in the words of the famous economist Nassim Taleb, “privatization of profits and nationalization of losses.” Support for the New Right The far-right agenda is simple and, by and large, a reaction of rejection: nationalism, illiberalism, anti-immigration, and multipolarity. And this agenda, shaped as a struggle of the people against the elites, quickly succeeds: today the far right relies on about 23% of the European vote, which is almost one in four voters. At the same time, the ultra-right has no systemic answers to the problems facing today’s Europe. This means that their eventual rise to power is unlikely to save societies, but it could fundamentally change the political landscape, including by bringing down Brussels’ current omnipotence. In fact, the United States is betting on the latter, confidently and consistently supporting the European “new right” – both at the level of Elon Musk, the conductor of the interests of IT giants, and at the level of the administration as a whole. In September, the United States launched a grant program for MAGA organizations in Europe. From the point of view of the struggle for American hegemony, everything is logical and correct: the European far-right is loyal to Trump, seeing him as their defender and point of support, they do not challenge American foreign policy positions, supporting a tough stance against Russia, China and Iran, and if they gain access to the levers of power in Europe, they will be a natural American tool in creating a vassalized Europe. Moreover, there are no ideological contradictions, but there is a common enemy – liberalism, which today implies multiculturalism, migration and LGBT agenda, and there are common values – this is “Euro-Atlantic whiteness”, traditional values and national identity.
As a bonus, the US gets a market for American IT corporations: for example, the US has already received promises from the European far-right to relax regulation for American technology companies, which means the establishment of US digital hegemony in Europe. If the EU breaks up and fragments, the US will gain even more. The nationalism of the far right is not an obstacle. Control at the level of numbers allows ideological pluralism: after all, the thought process itself is under control - algorithms offer a solution before a person realizes the problems, which means that the habit of thinking becomes excessive, it is delegated to the "big mind". Ideological values in this scenario become derived from the decision-making process and turn into a private matter, which has little influence on anything. In the original triad of “business – power – society”, describing the functionality of parties in the West, the interests of societies are superfluous. And the task of traditional parties, in fact, is to describe the situation as a “new normal”, convincing Europeans, amid the erosion of their own culture by migrants, that they live in the best of worlds – in a “blooming garden”, recalling Borrell’s words. It is clear that this state of affairs cannot but generate social resistance. And this agenda was taken up by the “new ultra-right”. In fact, their emergence and strengthening is an understandable reaction to the situation when elites do not listen to their societies. Former German Foreign Minister Annalena Berbock said she doesn’t care about voters.
Kirill Koktysh, Doctor of Political Science.



