The court refused the tuna who challenged the fine of car sharing for an accident

A resident of Tula Skorynina O.A. appealed to the court with a claim to PJSC “Karsharing Russia”, demanding compensation for moral damage for psychological pressure and threats. As reported by “MK in Tula” in the joint press service of the courts and the regional DSD, in March 2026, she issued a short-term rental car through the application, and in April the landlord charged her with a fine for an accident, which she denies.

According to the plaintiff, employees of the company demand payment of a fine and threaten to prevent the use of car sharing. She asked to recover 50 thousand rubles of compensation, a fine of 50% of the amount awarded and oblige the defendant to withdraw the fine and annul information about the accident.

But the court found that due to the fault of the plaintiff, the landlord suffered damage in the amount of the cost of restoration repairs, there is no evidence of its compensation and violation of the plaintiff's rights.

The decision of October 6, 2026 left the claim without satisfaction, the decision has not yet entered into force.

Earlier, “MK in Tula” reported that the court refused “AlfaInsurance” in the recovery of 120 thousand from a local resident. The cause was an accident in June 2024, after which the insurance paid for repairs of 240 thousand and asked the defendant half of the amount, but the court refused.